Sunday, August 30, 2009

hell, and other light topics..

Tonight we looked at the objection which is all too familiar and all too emotive : How can a loving God send people to Hell? I'll try to give the brief run-down!

There were a few questions behind the question...

1. What sort of God do you want?
The main point Michael made was that we are happy to hold that the character of God includes love and mercy, but that we overlook that He is also a JUST God.
His justice demands He hold to account all those who have done wrong. Interestingly, it is the upholding of our own legal justice system that gives us a greater degree of security and order than otherwise. A lack of a justice system secretly nourishes violence and increases the occurrence of retaliatory behaviour.

2. Does the punishment exceed the crime?
The big problem a lot of people have with the idea of hell, is that it seems hugely unreasonable for a finite life of occasional sin to incur an infinite punishment. It seems totally disproportionate.
Michael suggested that this reflected a misunderstanding of the seriousness of sin. For example: we don't hand down sentences of 25 - Life because a person has spent 25 years to commit a crime. The punishment isn't determined by the amount of time it took to commit the crime. It's determined by the seriousness of the crime.
Arguably, there is nothing worse you can do in this life than snub, mock and ignore the God who gave you life in the first place.
It's been said that Hell is ones freely chosen identity apart from God.

3. Why doesn't God just forgive everyone?
In short, because it would be immoral. It dehumanises us, robbing us of the right to choose. GK Chesterton says that "Hell is God's great compliment to the reality of human freedom and the dignity of human choice."

4. Why doesn't God just annihilate unbelievers on judgement day, rather than making them endure an eternity of torment?
I didn't really catch this point. He referred to Matt 25's parable of the sheep and the goats, and how it doesn't honour their choice. "Hell is the greatest monument to human freedom," according to CS Lewis.

This drew him to the conclusion that God already HAS DONE all He can do. He gave up His precious life so that we could avoid that end. He also warns us - Jesus speaks of hell more than anyone! Matt 18.9's reference to weeping and gnashing of teeth speaks more about the torment of regret of the unbeliever than their agonising pain.

In light of that, what we can do is heed His warning and make peace with God through the means He has graciously provided.
Also, those who are already united to Jesus must repent of their fear of speaking about Jesus, and of the coming judgement. If you really love people, are you going to keep silent about where they're headed? Won't you warn them, if you love them?

54 comments:

Otto said...

Hi Steph, have left an essay way too late (due tomorrow) so I hope you'll forgive me for replying with a link, which is from which I have based much of my thinking on this matter.

http://www.ebonmusings.org/atheism/infinitepunishment.html

Peace
Otto

Unknown said...

I'll preface this with the fact that I’ve done very little reading on this stuff (unlike Otto that little stalker) but I felt a sudden desire to respond with my humble opinions! A few things: I’m not religious, I’m fairly certain I have a subconscious (I suppose now that I’m aware of it it’s now very much conscious) intolerance for Christianity thanks to it’s association with much of American culture, and it’s 3am.

My biggest issue with your argument here is that you are humanising the reasoning of a god. Whilst it's a fairly effective technique used by many writers (not just relating to Christianity), it’s supporting a seemingly correct conclusion with false evidence.

1.
Firstly, you apply our notions of justice to the reasoning of God for his behaviour. Justice is an extremely relative concept, as I’m sure you would have witnessed from any travel you’ve done. Ever since we’ve been able to interact as societal creatures we have formed mutual agreements within our communities based on our moral and ethical values to include or exclude certain people, to allow or disallow certain behaviour, to punish or reward certain acts and so forth.

My point is that these agreements are the fundamental basis of a society’s justice system, and between different societies, notions of justice change quite distinctly. Yes, many of the more basic ‘agreements’ are shared in most societies, such as disallowing murder, but what about the societies which have a very different system of values?

Ironically, not even the Ten Commandments can be realistically seen as universal values. On the more extreme end there are cultures which excuse murder if it clears a family of shame, or in a society which values grace and agility, successful thievery is viewed as an enviable act by much of the lower class (see Rome).

I hope you can see my point that using a concept so subjective to justify God’s reasoning for his actions is rather fallacious.

Unknown said...

2.
Once again your argument here appears to be valid; however you’ve come to a logically unsound conclusion. You liken hell to prison, and in that comparison you involve our justice system.

In contemporary western society (excluding societies which practice capital punishment) we build prisons to protect the innocent and rehabilitate the guilty. If you are convicted of a crime and given a long sentence, the assumption is that you will leave the prison at the end of the sentence rehabilitated, and highly unlikely to repeat the offense (yet another cultural shift in our concept of justice from days where capital punishment was the norm for what we now see as minor crimes). Life sentences with no possibility of parole are most commonly given to repeat offenders or those who have been deemed incapable of rehabilitation.

I agree with you that the punishment is rarely determined by the time it took to commit a crime. A convicted murder may have spent 40 years living an innocent crime free life, and then spends 30 seconds committing a crime of passion. Are they imprisoned for 25 years because of the severity of the crime? Yes, but not only is it to serve as a cultural deterrent for murder, it is proportionate to the rehabilitation time. The person has proven they are capable of unrestrained and impulsive acts of violence and as a result they are kept away from the public in an attempt to protect and rehabilitate, so that one day they can re-enter society. The goal is not to have them rot in prison for 25 years to think about what they’ve done, and then come out ‘punished’ yet unchanged.

Hell is in no way similar to our concept of prison’s role in our justice system. You commit a ‘serious crime’ against God, you are judged by God, and then go to God’s prison for eternity with no possibility of redemption or rehabilitation. Where’s the similarity there?

You could argue that the opportunity for redemption and rehabilitation comes in life after one has committed the offence against God (in the act of repenting and embracing God, or however it’s done!), but how is that fair? You are given a finite time for spiritual rehabilitation, and if you don’t do it in that tiny space of time, you go to spiritual prison for life. Doesn’t this then suggest that we are even more merciful, loving and forgiving than God? Our concepts of justice embrace the value of life more than the concepts of heaven and hell, so how can it be suggested that our values are the same to God’s?

3.
I suppose I agree with you here that free choice and universal forgiveness coexisting would be rather redundant seeing as it’d be essentially eliminating negative consequence from our lives. Although I do think he probably could have picked a better system of justice from the rack, perhaps with some prospect of ascending to heaven post-rehab.

4.
The first thought I had here was that annihilating all unbelievers would be directly selecting for any genetic predisposition or cultural influence to religious inquiry. I don’t suppose God is a great believer in natural selection though…

Anyway, there’s not much for me to say about the idea that ‘God already HAS DONE all he can do’. I suppose Jesus’ death is probably a ‘you had to be there’ situation for me in the grand scheme of things, given that God is all powerful and probably could have mustered up something a bit more explicit if he wanted to get his point across that you have X years to repent and accept him, else you perish in hell for eternity.

Some more irony here… just as I finished that last paragraph I suddenly realised that if I did believe this situation (that God’s system of justice is so different to ours in that there is an expiry date for rehabilitation) I’d probably be running around the streets with the bible that I would have just purchased, yelling at everyone I cared about to repent before they die and get sent to hell for eternity with no conceivable chance of escape.

Unknown said...

To be honest, I pretty much disagree with every point, though I should make it clear that I'm an atheist.

1. Firstly, our justice system is not primarily about punishment: it is about preventing re-offending. Punishment is an element of this, but the most significant is education, counselling and providing a way out of environments that encourage crime. Unfortunately, these ideals are not always met in the present system, but they are there nonetheless.

Secondly, while the Bible may seem like sufficient warning to a Christian, it certainly does not to non-Christians. For one, it is riddled with holes that, even if they can be explained away, require more effort to rationalise than would be expected of a divinely originated work. But ignoring that the Bible at least appears inconsistent and that the estimated 33,830 denominations (and that's just Protestantism, 2001 World Christian Encyclopedia, Oxford University Press) disagree on almost everything, how does it seem right that such a massive, indeed eternal, punishment is given notice by a few iron age goatherds? Why are we expected to make a decision on such flimsy information? Where is the writing in the sky, or at least any genuine evidence that any of the Bible's message is true?

2. Imagine a person does something so bad that the legal system wants to imprison them for a thousand years. Imagine they can do that using some hypothetical life-prolonging method. It would have to be a pretty heinous crime that merited such a sentence, but certainly conceivable. What about a million years, a billion or 10^70 years? When more years have elapsed than there are atoms in the universe and some non-Christian who tried their hardest to be a good person is still being tortured, with the prospect of not just one but an infinite number of these sentences ahead of them, where is the mercy of God?

And how could a human be expected to comprehend such a punishment, anyway? I can barely imagine living to twice my current age, let alone a trillion times that. To use the legal terminology: there is no informed consent. We don't know what we're agreeing to. If we truly knew the magnitude of what we were heading towards, and further believed that it was truly so rather than having to trust the spurious and poorly-written mythology of an immoral, ignorant society, nobody would think twice. But a thousand years in and you bet I'd be screaming my repentance if such a thing were true. Yet God, his angels and all the souls of Christians sit in heaven watching me gnash my teeth and do nothing. Does it seem fair that we enter into this contract against our will, without full knowledge of the conditions and outcomes, and suffer a punishment more terrible than would ever be ordered by a loving human parent?

3. How does it rob us of the right to choose? I could still choose to sin if I wanted to. If I wanted to suffer for all eternity I could choose that too. If I wanted to get out of God's presence I could plot to overthrow him, or everyday blaspheme and desecrate his temple. If anything an eternal hell robs us of the right to choose. God imposes the punishment on man. What if I told you that, unless you hopped on one foot for 5 minutes every day for the rest of your life you be stabbed with a pitchfork all day long in the afterlife. Does it seem fair that I, arbitrarily, introduce the standard and that you, unwillingly, are forced into it? Does it seem right that such a matter would be brought to your attention by another human rather than a deity, or even a deity's messenger?

4. Same as above. Surely the best option would be the simplest: ask people once they die. When I line up outside the pearly gates and God says "Will you be flying Air Hell today?" you can bet your bottom dollar I'll choose annihilation.

Unknown said...

Because really, I didn't choose hell. I chose not to believe in God (well arguably I didn't choose, it just happened and as much as I tried to force the belief it didn't stay forced). God is the one who says "Oh and not believing means hell, so there." Why is he allowed to make an arbitrary link between one non-act (not believing is an act like not collecting stamps is a hobby) and a punishment when we aren't? If it was a reward it would be fine: anybody can give a reward to anybody else they want, no matter how "unfair" it is. But a punishment? We give people who torture others to death for their crimes (once again, decided arbitrarily by the individual) a life sentence. How come God gets off scot-free?

The only rationalisations of hell revolve around the concept of absolute morality. That is, that what God calls sin is objectively wrong. There are several problems there. Why aren't we all aware of this absolute morality? Morality shifts with the times, and some people lack any common morality with others (sociopaths for example). And if the morality is objective, is it greater than God or arbitrary? Either absolute morality exists regardless of God's will - in which case God is subject to it - or it is arbitrarily decided by God according to his own standard. If it is arbitrary then hell is unjust, through and through. If it is external to God then whence comes it?

Jared said...

Hm, looks like 1 and 2 have been covered pretty comprehensively but I'd like to chime in on 3 & 4. The theme seems to be, Hell exists because we have free will, or vice versa. The problem I have discussing free will with a Christian (and I'm sorry to bring this up because I'm sure we've all heard it a hundred times) is that the notion of free will is such a paradox in Christian theory. So, riddle me this, Steph:

On one hand we have Christians running around saying, 'It was part of God's plan,' every time something bad happens to make themselves feel better, and we have Jesus knowing Judas would betray him, that dude would deny him 3 times etc. I've been told that God knows what I'm going to do, what I'm thinking at every moment and even that I secretly don't mind T.I.'s latest album.

On the other hand God's gone ahead and created HELL and told us that if we don't choose to believe in and worship him (on the basis of some fairly dubious evidence, I might add) that we'll spend eternity (ETERNITY!) burning in it. Clearly it's up to us to make the right choice and accept him.

Therein lies the problem. We're told that at the same time we have free will and that we don't.
Either:
a) everything really does happen according to God's plan. In that case, he made me, and he engineered my brain in such a way that I would choose to become an atheist. He also created people in remote regions who would never hear the word of God, who will no doubt end up in Hell. He created millions of people before Jesus was even born who are all presumably in Hell too. He even created gay people. Essentially God created people who he knew from the time they were born would end up burning in Hell for eternity. If you believe in this all-knowing and all-powerful God's plan then you believe he created me, made me think the way I do, just so that he can kill me later. Nice just, merciful God you've got there.

OPTION THE b: It really is up to us to make our own mind up based on the evidence we've been presented with. Probably not the fairest situation to be placed in considering the stakes and the fact that the most reliable info we have on the matter has been passed down to us over a couple of millennia from a society who believed in demons and thought the earth was flat, but I digress. The biggest problem for Christians in this reality is that God isn't actually all that omniscient or omnipotent, because either he doesn't know what I'm thinking or has no power to affect what I do. You may argue that he is but chooses not to exercise his power and lets me make up my own mind, but in this case he is clearly an asshole.
Epicurus, ladies and gentlemen:
http://i28.tinypic.com/169kpzc.jpg

tl;dr:
The issue of free will is a fundamental flaw in Christian logic. Far from being a justification for sending people to Hell, it essentially undermines your entire religion.

I forget what we were talking about.

Tony said...

In regards to the comments about prison - there are numerous models (of justice?) that lie behind various systems of imprisonment. The main/key ones are:
1. Deterrent (ie stop you doing it again)
2. Protective (ie to protect others from you)
3. Rehabilitative (to make the criminal "better")
4. Retributive (ie to punish you in a manner relative to the crime you have committed).

Our system of jail contains elements of all of these - although there has been a move away from the fourth to the others.
I would argue that the fourth is only truly "just" - and that the others can lead you to inappropriate levels of "punishment" (either too excessive or too weak).
As examples:
(i) What stops you cutting the hand off of a petty thief? If you hold to views 1 or 2 (or possibly 3) then not a great deal.
(ii) Imagine a pill that could be given to a child sex-offender - that would prevent the individual committing such acts in the future - would it be sufficient to give the convicted criminal such a pill and allow them to go free? Or would further incarceration be required? If you think that they should in some sense "pay a price" for their crime - that is retributive justice.

The question with hell is "does the punishment fit the crime?"
If hell is indeed God giving people what they want - that is existence without him - then the answer would have to be "yes".

Jared said...

"Hell is indeed God giving people what they want - that is existence without him".
I'm just gonna go ahead and quote Richard on this because there's no point going over this again:
"Not believing is an act like not collecting stamps is a hobby".

We're not born believing in Jesus. The default setting here is no belief. We grow up believing in nothing, then at some point in our development, about the same time we're told about Santa and the Tooth Fairy, we're presented with some stories about a dude getting eaten by a whale and an ark with every single animal ever on it (not dinosaurs though, the Devil put fossils there to trick us). We're told that this God exists who knows everything and will keep us safe. Cool. I'm 8 years old. Cool.

As we grow older and more skeptical in light of that whole Santa Clause thing we ask more questions about the fundamental principles of Christianity, as well as all the contradictions in the Bible. For the most part we are given "You can't expect to understand God, he's divine and beyond our human comprehension", which essentially amounts to "a wizard did it".
Which is cool, but we wouldn't be doing our job as intelligent humans if we didn't examine both sides of the argument, and explore the possibility that this is all some nonsensical mysticism.

So we ask for more evidence. Like, some real concrete evidence that what you're saying is true (and no, the Bible isn't evidence). Unfortunately no evidence can be given. Miracles appeared to die out at a rate which coincided strangely with advances in technology, God hasn't deemed it necessary to send us any concrete signs of his existence in the last 2000 years and even the first person accounts of Jesus' life FROM THE BIBLE differ greatly in their recollection of the events. Not to mention the fact that the whole world is completely and utterly FUCKED UP. I'd be more inclined to believe you if you said we already were in Hell, rather than somewhere watched over at all times by an omnipotent and all-loving God.

What I'm trying to get to here is an illustration of the situation most atheists/agnostics are in. We're here enjoying our lives without having to believe in an invisible man in the sky. We're then presented with Christianity and we go, "OK, that's pretty nice I guess, but why should I believe this? You haven't really sold me on it, there's a fair few things that don't make sense and if it's all the same to you I think I'll just keep on keeping on until I'm actually given a reason to believe this".

Which brings me back to your post. You essentially just said that the only 'just' way of dealing with this type of person is to torture them for eternity.
What
The
Fuck?
Torture for eternity!
You think shit would suck if you got eaten by a sarlacc and got digested over 1000 years? 1000 years is pocket change to eternity. And we're not Boba Fett so we can't bust outta there either.

"Does the punishment fit the crime?
...
Yes."
So apparently the punishment for being a reasonable, level-headed person who relies on concrete facts and logic rather than millenia-old superstition and good feelings when making life-altering decisions is eternal torture in Hell. This is what Christians actually believe? You're just embarrassing yourself now, man...

Otto said...

I always find it hard not to feel insulted and angry when some holier-than-thou Christian slaps his distorted and reprehensible sense of justice in my face.
But adequately expressing my indignation wouldn't be in the spirit of good argument, so I shall abstain.
I'm still interested to see if any Christian can adequately counter the points raised here.

Incidentally, what stops us from cutting the hand off a petty thief, is a sense of ethics and morality that have evolved past the Iron Age. If you can't see that then we seriously have a problem.

Tony said...

@ Richard
"Why is he allowed to make an arbitrary link between one non-act (not believing is an act like not collecting stamps is a hobby) and a punishment when we aren't?"

Even non-acts will have certain non-arbitrary links. Continuing with your example - if you choose not to collect stamps (and continue to refuse to collect stamps despite the urgings and encouragement of your stamp collecting friends) because you do not want any part of stamp collecting - then you will rightly be refused entry to the "Stamp Collectors Club Meeting" and will miss all the attendant benefits that come from being a member.

@ Jared
I'm sorry if my "punishment fit the crime" line struck a nerve - it was really just meant to be picking up on the discussion about justice and punishment.
As you can see from my above response to Richard - I've tried to answer his objection using the illustration he began with.

I was intrigued by your illustration of the "journey of the agnostic/atheist" - as in some ways it parallels my own (and diverges significantly at others). I grew up agnostic - and was always skeptical of both Santa and the Tooth Fairy (my folks never made a big deal about them) but was impressed with what I heard of Jesus (but then my folks never made a big deal about him either). It wasn't until I was an adult that I sort to figure out who I thought Jesus was and what he had done. As I read the bible for myself (and a bunch of other stuff as well) I became convinced of its explanation for why the world was f*cked up, why I was f*cked up and what God had done about it in sending Jesus.

@Otto
"What stops us from cutting the hand off a petty thief?" Was a question designed to stimulate thought about the basis for your views on justice. I know what stops me advocating such a type of "justice" (that I hold to retributive justice) - and that is the grounds on which I will argue.
I can't help but think that the people or cultures around the world who would hold that it is appropriate to cut off a thief's hand wouldn't consider your comments about having "a sense of ethics and morality that have evolved past the Iron Age" as a "slap in the face" from someone who holds a "distorted and reprehensible" sense of justice arising out of their own sense of cultural superiority.

e.b. said...

For the sake of justice, I'd totally want to overthrow God, if I believed he existed.
Essentially, he's a tyrannical, narcissistic despot who has seriously got the worst concept of justice ever. If this was a human dude (or dudette) ruling Australia no one would stand for it!
If you look at the notions of morality from Mosaic law etc, he's really got some fucked up ideas. I mean, why is it that making idols (even if they're representations of god himself if one goes with the whole iconoclasm argument) is listed as a sin in the ten commandments, but rape, child abuse etc are not??!
So how do we know these things are wrong if God never said anything about them?
On God's idea of justice, would someone who molested children, but thought they were doing so as part of God's will (i.e. members of the YFZ cult) go to heaven or hell?

Obviously morality is a human construct that didn't originate from God, but perhaps from an inbuilt sense of empathy that results from our evolution as creatures who function best in the context of a tribe or society. And this is what I think has led to the different sets of value systems that we see around the world today - as we all have evolved in different societies and cultural groups.

Also, I don't think you can compare God's ideas of justice and punishment to our modern justice system. At least we're allowed a fair trial (in most cases) in which we can make some sort of argument for our own defense.
But I suppose, considering that God is omniscient and omnipotent, there is no need for witnesses, lawyers, juries and impartial judgments. But then again, this brings us back to Jared's point: if God KNEW that we were going to commit a sin, and didn't use his all extensive power to say, WAIT, STOP! I'M REAL AND WHAT YOU'RE DOING IS A SIN etc, why did he create us?
He's probably hella bored up there and in need of some (pretty damn sadistic) entertainment.
But, oh wait, I'm forgetting something, aren't I? He did do something. That's right. He sent us his son!
Well....that was two thousand and nine years ago. He's been pretty lazy since then, hasn't he? And he hasn't used his omnipotence to leave us with the best of evidence. The Bible, as people have already said here, is really not much to go on. It's rather contradictory, and most of it was written at least a hundred years after Jesus's death. Not by witnesses. So it's hearsay, which wouldn't stand up in court.
And I don't believe in it, because I'm not inclined to make epic conclusions about the purpose of my existence and the direction of my life without the presence of some hardcore evidence. And if God is real, then I'm going to Hell, for having a logical mind with a healthy dose of skepticism.

Screw that.

Also, if God is real, and omnipotent, omniscient, I don't need to point out the obvious conclusion that he can't be all loving. The world is shit. People constantly experience immeasurable suffering for no apparent reason. Some justice in that, God.
What's the point of it? Is it some ridiculously stringent and unfair test of faith?
If you're going to punish innocent people then I don't want to go to your stupid heaven, God.

But those child molesters, rapists, murderers, if they repent, they'll go heaven, right?


I've got one more question, one that has been bothering me for the past nine years and which I've never received a satisfactory answer to.
What's the role of the Devil in all of this?
How can he be such a threat to God that he was able to tempt Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, and/or that he is responsible for seemingly random occurrences of violence, natural disaster etc, if God is all powerful?
Or does God do all that hurricane/ bushfire/swine flu shit?
Alternately, isn't he still one of God's minions, as he is overseeing Hell and punishing God's dissenters? Why doesn't he high five them instead of punishing them?

What's the deal there?

Jared said...

When I was a little kid I was impressed with what I heard of Wolverine, but that didn't make him any more real. While something sounding nice and comforting to you may present a deterrent to disbelief in your own mind, it doesn't make it any more credible in reality.
All you've said in the way of refuting what I've written is that you heard the story of Jesus and you liked it. Upon further critical examination (and I use the term lightly) you liked it more.

I'm reading and re-reading your post looking for anything in the way of the evidence I asked for in my last post and there is genuinely none to be found. And you appear to have completely disregarded my post about the free will paradox. I've asked many Christians about that conundrum over the past few years, including Christian Studies teachers (i.e. people who are legitimately qualified to indoctrinate children with this stuff) and I am yet to hear anything back more substantial than "Hmm, you've given me a lot to think about, thank you". So I suppose it's not surprising you'd just ignore it rather than submit to the possibility that your belief system is patently false.

Anyway, back to what I was saying before. I don't think I have much more to add which I haven't already said in my previous post. I get that all the things about God taking care of us, and people going to Heaven when they die and bad things happening for a reason are comforting thoughts. If the story of Jesus were true that'd be freaking incredible.
The fact of the matter is, I like to think of myself as a rational, intelligent human being and as such I submit propositions to inquiry before accepting them as truth.
"Because how sweet would it be if it were true" does not constitute proof.
When someone tells me a story as fantastic and incredible as the story of Jesus, as well as all the other stories in the Bible, it is not unreasonable for me to ask for them to prove it. To this date no such evidence has been provided.
I guess I'll just go to Hell then. My bad.

Unknown said...

@ nick- My biggest issue with your argument here is that you are humanising the reasoning of a god.

i don't see why this is an issue: As a christian i believe that God reveals himself as a person, a human being, Jesus Christ who we can know. People ate with him, farted with him, drank with him. He was human and the very being of God. We are allowed to humanise his reasoning

@jared

"Which brings me back to your post. You essentially just said that the only 'just' way of dealing with this type of person is to torture them for eternity.
What
The
Fuck?
Torture for eternity!
You think shit would suck if you got eaten by a sarlacc and got digested over 1000 years? 1000 years is pocket change to eternity. And we're not Boba Fett so we can't bust outta there either."

1) nice. lol. i appreciate the star wars ref, and i take your point about the punishment appearing disproportionate to the crime.

I guess for me as a christian the issue is that the crime is massive.

Human beings were created to be in relationship with God and to glorify him. That's what we're hear for. That's our mission in life. I can't think of any bigger way to stuff up our life than to ignore God. Every cell, molecule and atom in our being exists to glorify God, and we choose to ignore him. That's just really big, and eternal state of destruction and pain (which is i think what all the fire metaphors are on about) seems like an appropriate response

1 thing to add, I hope as you see what a christian thinks about hell you understand why all you're christian friends keep on trying to talk to you about jesus... we desperately don't want to see people in hell, and think that the way out is Jesus, so we will keep trying to get you to consider him.

Unknown said...

@richard

"Where is the writing in the sky, or at least any genuine evidence that any of the Bible's message is true?"

good question. That is the big one for this whole issue. If there is no good evidence then punishment is unfair, unwarranted and nasty.

But Jesus Christ rose from the dead. This is a historical claim we can investigate. This is a moment in history we are called to thin about.

If Jesus was raised from the dead then he is the one God gave authority to to tell us about this stuff, and he warns us explicitly.

TO check out evidence for Christ rising from the dead, there are plaenty of good places. Serious thinking- i'd go NT Wright "the ressurection and the son of God". something a bit more accessible, check out http://andrewerrington.wordpress.com/resources/ and click on the essay "on the first day of the week"

e.b. said...

Dave,
I really don't think fire and brimstone and eternal excruciating pain is an appropriate response to not believing in something on the basis of an extreme lack of evidence. Why did God give humans logical minds if he actually desired us to go against them? Does he want us to fail?
I'm afraid that I can only conclude from this that he's one bored, sadistic dude.
And if we're going to talk about proportionality here, I'd like to know whether you think it's fair that someone who committed atrocious crimes against humanity, but who repents and asks God for forgiveness moments before death out of cowardly fear, or even someone who has believed in God all along, may not go through the whole brimstone process?

e.b. said...

Again, Dave:

In regards to evidence for Christ's rising from the dead, yes, this is a very important historical claim which we can investigate. And people have done so.
Obviously if they'd found some concrete proof we'd all be Christian.
Might I again remind you that much of the material in the Bible as we know it today was selected by ancient Roman and Byzantine elites who existed three hundred years after Christ's death, and who probably wanted to select the materials that would work best for their own political agendas. If you don't know what I'm talking about, google/wiki the Councils of Nicaea, Chalcedon, etc.

Jared said...

@dave:

How do you know God is real?
Jesus rose from the dead.

How do you know Jesus rose from the dead?
It says so in the Bible.

How do you know the Bible is the truth?
Because it's the word of God.

How do you know God is real?

Unknown said...

eb.

I appreciate your thoughts, but let me say i do not think God wants us to leave our logical minds at the door. He wants us to use them. I am in my final semester of a science degree at sydney uni, majoring in physics and philosophy, and I think God wants me to use m logical mind considering him as much as much or more than my quantum mechanics lecturer wants me to use it.

Jesus Calls people to think. Anxious about whether we can think God provides for us? Matthew 6- consider the birds! think about our world! In fact Romans 12 pleads with christians to "be transformed by the renewing of your minds" aka think about it!. This is why i put forward the ressurection as the basis for faith- the christian claim is that this is a moment in history that occured, and we can establish that by being good historians just like we can establish how the roman empire fell.

Your question about people who repent at the end really hits on a core issue here. Thankyou very much for asking it. Why can someone who has not led a just life but who repents be saved? we need to feel the personal weight of this question. I have not led a just life. How can i be saved? By looking at our own lives, none of us can be saved. God does not want to send people to hell. He loves people. SO much that he sent his son, Jesus Christ, to take the punishment of death that i deserve, and all people who lead imperfect lives lead, so that in repentance we can gain the reward Jesus deserves, of life with God. Mercy triumphs over judgement.

That being said, God knows and judges hearts and minds. It's not a matter of 'pretending to repent' out of cowardice. Repentance is an act of the heart.

cheers. thanks for your thoughts.

Unknown said...

@Jared

The bible is not the only good sources for Jesus rising for the dead. Nor do i believe it out of blind faith.

I believe it with reason and reflection.

Please go to that link i posted for a better explanation, but let me give you a taster

1) The early disciples Died for saying That Jesus Christ rose from the dead. multiple people don't independantly die for refusing to admit a lie.

2) The church starts in Jerusalem! same place Jesus is buried! if Jesus was still dead why did no one produce his body

3) Anyone ever heard of a guy called Bar kochba? i doubt it. He was a much more succesful Jewish Messiah than Jesus. He threw the romans out of Israel. He even printed his own coins, starting with year one. But the romans defeated him, and his followers abandoned him. no one kept proclaiming him as a messiah, because a dead messiah is no messiah! Why did Jesus' followers keep living for him long after he died? why were they willing to give up all for him? Because he rose from the dead.

e.b. said...

Could someone please answer my question about the Devil?
God's minion or nemesis?

Unknown said...

eb,

i don't quite understand the question. please flesh it out. Nemesis. He is Evil, God hates evil... but not nemesis in the sense of conparable, ying ang yang style. God is supremely more powerful than the devil. Not sure i get the question.

with regards to hell- The devil doesn't run hell. Hell is where the Devil gets punished.

e.b. said...

Then who creates the evil in the world?
And if the devil is stuck in hell, how does he sneak out and tempt people?

Unknown said...

quick answer:
1) Evil is in the world because humans (like me!) have chosen to disobey God, and in that decision bring evil into the world. The bible isn't explicit about how the devil comes into the picture. Because Humans- who were made stewards of the world- rebelled, the world has become imperfect (hence earthquakes etc.)

2) The devil isn't in hell yet. He gets smashed to hell on judgement day.

Unknown said...

Akenbak: it's certainly well within the rights of the stamp-collecting group to withhold whatever membership rewards they see fit from a non-stamp-collector, and I have no problem with such a thing. However hell is not merely the "denial of a reward" but the active visitation of eternal torture upon somebody whose 'greatest' crime was that they didn't subscribe to a two-thousand year old fairytale, preferring the reliable evidence of reality.

A common apologetic in this instance is to claim that hell is not in fact a punishment but simply the absence of a reward. This is usually done using circumlocution or equivocation, but at its core relies upon the assertion that hell is inevitable and would happen with or without god in the picture, though this is never stated. If such a thing were true then it would still fail on moralistic grounds: a person who could prevent tremendous suffering with no real cost to themselves is guilty by inaction. God could annihilate non-believers instead of leaving them to their 'fate', or at the very least offer them a choice in the matter after they died (i.e. once it became apparent that they were actually making a choice, not simply not-stamp-collecting).

Dave: unfortunately, as a historical investigation the claim of Christ's resurrection falls squarely on its face. Having spent the first 17 years of my life as a Christian (making the commitment to Jesus at 11 and being a devout, albeit liberal, believer until finally exposed to real, rather than strawman, counter-arguments at 17) I am familiar with the arguments and 'facts' of the matter.

It should be apparent that there is no extra-biblical evidence that Jesus rose from the dead. The earliest written attestations to it appear in some of the epistles (and presumably other, unseen communications) and then nothing until the Christians of later centuries. The Bible itself is sketchy on the details: how many women found Jesus' tomb empty: 1, 2, 3 or more than 3? Was the stone already rolled away? Had the sun already risen? Was there an earthquake? Did they find a young man, two men, one angel or two angels? When, where and how did those figures appear? What did they say? Was/were Mary/the women afraid and confused, afraid and joyous or simply calm and accusative? Did the tell anyone immediately after - the disciples, nobody or a nearby angel? Did the disciples believe the women or did Jesus appear to them? Where and to whom did Jesus first appear? What did he say, and did they recognise him when they saw him? Why does 1 Corinthians disagree with the gospels about these appearances? Why do only two gospels mention the ascension?

Far from presenting a consistent account of a factual resurrection, the gospels and 1 Corinthians demonstrate an early church that was struggling to incorporate recently created mythology into the pre-death apocalyptic prophesying of Jesus. It is also interesting that some passages from the gospels are exact copies of each other. Matthew, Mark and Luke for example sometimes use identical wording in recounting "eye-witness" testimony. Either parts of all three were copied from a pre-existing document or one or more were copied from each other.

Interestingly, John, which shares little identical wording with the other three gospels, is the most divergent in its account of the resurrection, yet the other three still have differences. The most logical hypothesis is that the resurrection story was a common rumour at the time that the gospel authors exploited to further their own agenda.

But still, if you or any other finds any physical or textual evidence that provides a solid account of the resurrection, it would overturn the notion that it is a manufactured story. Don't forget that resurrection stories are very common in the mythologies of ancient civilisations struggling with a fear of death. Many people throughout history supposedly died and subsequently appeared to the living. Why give more credence to the flawed account in the Bible than something found in Bullfinch's Mythology?

Jared said...

He's a scientist!? Oh no, my veneer of intellectual superiority is nullified!

OK I'm sorry, I guess I didn't make this clear enough. 2000 year old hearsay =/= evidence.

1) Any evidence you have to back up this point has to be dubious at best, solely based on the fact that it happened a couple of millenia ago. If memory serves the Roman Empire was wont to execute just about anyone for just about anything. While we're on the subject, a great deal of people were executed for being witches around the 1600's. I guess you believe in witches too.

2) A famous person's body disappears/is not put on display in a church in 30AD Jerusalem and the best explanation you can come up with is the body coming back to life and walking off. Why am I even bothering to argue with you...?

3) So basically if all the believers weren't wiped out by the Empire, it must be true? I'm guessing a dude who started to print his own coins was probably the biggest threat to the Empire, right next to Ewoks, so I'm not surprised he was run into the ground. Luckily Constantine integrated Christianity into Roman mythology, otherwise you'd be out having sex or something right now.
Anyway, why are you not Jewish then? Or Muslim? They make similar claims and have comparable legions of supporters. Thats about the only criteria you use when evaluating somethings credibility.

e.b. said...

Yay for sex!
Also, can we get past this whole 'THE WORLD IS SHAKING, THERE'S A HURRICANE, GOD IS ANGRY' mentality?
We've got scientific explanations for how earthquakes occur now (wouldn't you agree Dave, considering you do science?).
It's pretty ridiculous to think that something as massive as the Earth and all its bubbling magma would be determined by the actions of humans.

Unknown said...

ok. so i have an essay due tomorrow i have to go work on. otherwise i would love to stay and chat, so if i don't reply again for a while then that's why, ok?

but for now:
@richard, yes- luke and matthew both probably draw from marks account and from another source (Q). the fact that there is difference in the little details seems to be good evidence that they didn't conspire to fabricate a tale, but wrote down the important stuff and may have got some little details down differently. detailed variation in witnessing is a sign of authenticity.

@Jared, sorry if i expressed myself poorly. i don't believe Jesus rose because lots of others are. I believe because the eye witnesses were willing to die for saying what they did, which confirms to me that they were conviced what they said was true. Islam has no such great historical evidence, nor does it make a historically testable claim. Allah's visions are not testable in the same way as Jesus' ressurection

@eb- i agree. sorry if i explained myself poorly. I don't think earthquakes happen because God is angry. What i meant was that earthquakes happen because we live in a world that is imperfect, and we live in a world that is imperfect because humans are imperfect.

cheers. talk to you all again soon. thanks for the chat. have to go write an essay.

e.b. said...

Dave you're still saying that humans, little, fragile mortal beings we are, are the cause of the Earth's seismic activities (although I don't dispute that we've damaged the world with pollution but that's a different issue).
Does it not occur to you that the world has been around, in some imperfect state or another, for BILLIONS of years, an amount of time we can't even comprehend, and humans have been on it for a mere fraction of that time?

e.b. said...

Anyone going to step up the podium now that Dave has left?
Or should we call this a victory?

Jared said...

Wait dave I'm really confused now. This is starting to sound like some ridiculous fan fiction.

So now the Devil isn't even in Hell? Where is he then? And who's taking care of Hell??

On a slightly related tangent:
Adam and Eve were sitting pretty in the Garden of Eden, right? Sin wasn't around, until one day Eve ate from the Tree of Knowledge - committing the first sin - so God deemed it fit to torture her descendants for the rest of time.
If sin wasn't around until we humans caused it, what was the Devil doing slinking around the Garden of Eden? Clearly sin and evil existed before humans did, which raises some questions. Isn't God's beef really with the Devil then, and not with us? Its not our fault evil exists so why should we be punished for eternity? What the hell were you doing when the Devil was talking to Eve? [Side Note: Keep in mind, only after we ate from the tree did we gain knowledge of good and evil. Before that, how were we to know that what we were doing was wrong anyway?]

Where were we? I forget.

Anyway, onto your latest comment dave. Pretty sure I addressed what you just said in the first point of my last post. I agree that if what you said really is true that their conviction is commendable, but remember this is the conviction of a primitive superstitious people whose contemporaries also strongly believed that if they appeased the ocean god they'd have good day's fishing.
You'll have to excuse me for not taking their word for it.

Jared said...

New rule:

No Christians post until they've answered my first question about the free will paradox.

I am serious, I've asked this so many times and never been given an answer. If your belief system is as infallible as you claim you can clarify this for me. If you cannot I urge you to seriously rethink your worldview because you must realise it is fundamentally flawed.

e.b. said...

In regards to Adam and Eve, I'm just going to be the token feminist here and point out:
ISN'T IT INTERESTING THAT IT WAS EVE WHO WAS TEMPTED BY THE DEVIL
Obviously this fable (I am not sure how anyone could possibly believe it) was constructed by patriarchal elites in order to justify the confinement of women to the role of childbearer/raiser/slave to household and husband/second class citizen.

Also, so nice of God to punish generations and generations of Adam and Eve's descendants for their mistake (which WAS a mistake considering that, as Jared pointed out, they had no concept of good and evil)!

Isn't he a lovely chap?!

Shotgun not following

Jared said...

https://www.brooklynmuseum.org/eascfa/feminist_art_base/archive/images/369.1009.jpg
Pictured: Emilia

Sam said...

Belief is the psychological state in which an individual holds a proposition or premise to be true, beliefs are the assumptions we make about ourselves, about others in the world and about how we expect things to be.

Belief is not rational nor logical, as by definition belief is personal.

As such arguing rationally or logically about belief is inherently flawed, similar to Christianity.

steph said...

hey guys,

i'll post my thoughts when i've had the time to do it in a way that gives your insights justice. from my observations, it seems like there has been a lot of talking, but not much listening. i hope to avoid that by carefully considering what you have said.

but i'd appreciate it if you considered dropping the contempt for my friends because of what they believe.

i'm eager to engage and reason with you - but it's hard for me to do that graciously when you all ridicule me and what i believe. i don't say this with an antagonistic tone, at all - i say it with gentleness.

is that fair?

i'm not 'fighting' with you guys. as such, i'm not out for 'victory'. i would have hoped that were the case for you too.

grace and peace
xx

e.b. said...

Steph,
I'm sorry if our comments offended you. This is, after all, your blog!
But in my personal opinion Christianity is a sensitive issue for many people, whether or not they prescribe to its teachings. It is obviously very influential, particularly in the Western world, and many of us have been exposed to years of it at school or at home.
Someone, I think it was Dave, made the comment that Christians often vigorously try to inform their non-Christian friends about Jesus, for fear of them being sent to hell. And I suppose it must be frustrating. Well, for me, it's a similar concept. I believe that life is short, and is succeeded by nothingness. It's what you make of it, and the most important thing is thus to experience it to the full. Not to waste time following rules and ideas that are there without any sort of merit, or that have been used to justify wrongdoing, and have the potential to harm human fellowship.
Of course, that's just my opinion and you are of course entitled to your own. I will personally aim to be more polite in this discussion.
But I still want answers to some of the above questions, so I'd appreciate your take on matters.


Peace.

Jared said...

I tried to take this as lightheartedly as I could to begin with, which I hope was evident, but as is often the case with subjects people are passionate about, things escalate.
At least in my case I was happy to have a friendly debate until someone said I deserved to burn in Hell for eternity for wanting a bit more evidence. Its not just us harbouring contempt, please realise that...

But having said that (and I don't mean to say it in a way that exacerbates the situation either; it is merely raised in the interest of equality) I'm all for chillaxing a bit.

steph said...

thanks guys.

i'll get back to you soon.

much love xx

Tommy Judd said...

The biggest issue I see here is this: non-Christians feel Christians look down on them for not believing, and Christians feel their intelligence is being mocked for their beliefs.

Christians talking about hell is usually because they care about you, not because they want to rub it in your face... those who do, are douchebags and probably go to the Westboro baptist church.

Everyone here appears quite intelligent, so show some respect towards one-another. If you re-read each others' comments before replying, you may actually find that you're arguing over practically nothing.

I do get a sense every time such a discussion like this occurs, people associate belief apart from the belief of nothing after death with naivety, gullibility, stupidity etc. This is unfair, to be allowed to believe in nothing, you should also be allowed to believe in something.

Even Einstein saw, through the structural arrangement and scientific brilliance of the world, that God's existence was plausible... through his shear admiration.

I haven't read through everyone's post carefully yet but it looks like I will have to.

Jared said...

"The word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses, the Bible a collection of honorable but still primitive legends which are nevertheless pretty childish" - Albert Einstein, in a letter to philosopher Eric Gutkind in January 1954.

steph said...

All that says, Jared, is that Einstein didn't believe in the God of the Bible. What Tom says still stands - Einstein believed that the existence of God was plausible. I think you might appreciate what people say more if you listened more carefully? :)

A knowledge of the existence of something we cannot penetrate, of the manifestations of the profoundest reason and the most radiant beauty - it is this knowledge and this emotion that constitute the truly religious attitude; in this sense, and in this alone, I am a deeply religious man.
- Einstein

I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but have expressed it clearly. If something is in me which can be called religious then it is the unbounded admiration for the structure of the world so far as our science can reveal it. (Einstein, 1954)

I believe in Spinoza's God who reveals himself in the orderly harmony of what exists, not in a God who concerns himself with the fates and actions of human beings.
- Einstein

Jared said...

What credence do any of these quotes lend to your argument?
It essentially reiterates the assertion that the Judeo-Christian concept of God is absurd and fanciful, which is after all what we are arguing here.
I would call myself an atheist but I am open to the possibility of a "higher power". However there is no way I would worship this (these?) entities considering the state of the world and their apparent disinterest in it. Einstein appears to share my view. While a more complex being may exist (and still, there is no real proof) your concept of a perfect God who watches over our affairs at all times is still laughable.

I don't know why I just wrote that, you said it yourself in your first sentence.
"All that says, Jared, is that Einstein didn't believe in the God of the Bible."
The existence of the Christian God (as well as the associated implications of Christian mythology like Hell etc.) is all we have been debating in this thread. All those quotes do nothing if not strengthen our argument.

Tommy Judd said...

Re-post of the quote I was referring to:

"I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but have expressed it clearly. If something is in me which can be called religious then it is the unbounded admiration for the structure of the world so far as our science can reveal it." (Albert Einstein, 1954)

I'm not actually using Einstein as a point for the existence of God as much as a point for the existence of intelligent Christians.

This is the problem here, you don't listen to what I'm saying, I tried to be a bit of a referee, but apparently came across as one-sided.

You say you're open to the possibility of a higher power, yet argue against all points for Christianity, no matter what they are.

There was a point where I sunk into this rut of doubting "all that crap" about the existence of God and what was in the Bible. Brought upon by the distraction of "the real world" where people would drink up and not think outside the pub.

It's when you start thinking about yourself, about the existence of life on earth, what's outside this solar system, galaxy, the edge of the universe where time slows down because the expansion is slowing down... you start wanting more answers.

Christians don't claim to have all the answers, if they do, they're lying. In the same way, atheists don't have the answers either, they may blurt out "science" but science is full of theories masked as "facts" - which we will never know all the answers to.

I was surprised because I thought my post was quite clear, neutral and understandable.

Jared said...

Ok, I appreciate you trying to mediate the situation but I just didn't see how Einstein was proof of intelligent Christians because Einstein didn't believe in any Christian teachings so I wanted to point that out.

The problem I have is that a lot of Christians I talk to do claim to have all the answers. Science has never claimed this; it is nothing more than the pursuit of knowledge. Religious practice seems to be to start with a conclusion and then try to shoe-horn the evidence into the established contrivance. It's the mental calibre of someone who is so intellectually promiscuous that they will jump on a supernatural answer for things they don't immediately understand that puts the intellect of Christian collective in disrepute. I'm not content to sit back and say a wizard did it until we prove beyond doubt that a deity created the universe. Until that day I've got no reason to believe in a higher power and I'm happy to keep supporting science and progress in the hope that one day we'll really understand what's going on.

steph said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Tommy Judd said...

So you feel working towards the solution is the only option in life and not back-track from a proposed pre-existing one?

Doesn't science and mathematics do this all the time?

Everyone has a bias when it comes to these kinds of topics, which is why it's blacklisted from many social circles. People don't listen to the points, they listen for tone.

"Religious practice seems to be to start with a conclusion and then try to shoe-horn the evidence into the established contrivance. It's the mental calibre of someone who is so intellectually promiscuous that they will jump on a supernatural answer for things they don't immediately understand that puts the intellect of Christian collective in disrepute"

Now, I'm having to bite my lip a bit here, because your comment is quite insulting.

You say on the one hand that you appreciate my attempts at mediation, then try stirring me up by disregarding my intelligence.

You could just say "Meh, it's not really for me, I have no reason to believe in God or life after death, you think what you like" but you don't. You basically say: "You're only allowed to believe in nothing, but no one is allowed to believe in something -- if it extends beyond the physical, it does not exist"

The reason these kinds of debates happen so often, go around in circles, and result in no real conclusions is because it's two sides with reasonable opposing beliefs. At the end of the day, people just need to accept the other isn't going to budge, rather than get aggressive.

Having said that, the difference between the intent behind the Christian and the atheist, is that the Christian loves the atheist and wants to save them... so maybe warm up to that perspective even if you don't believe it.

Jared said...

The point I was trying to make is that science is usually open to the fact that it's wrong. That's why we constantly refine theories and why open discourse on scientific matters is encouraged, and this isn't always the case with most religions.

I genuinely am sorry if my comment about intelligent Christians offended you. I tried to make it not sound like a personal attack by referring the typical Christian as a whole. We were previously discussing the preconceived notion that Christians aren't as intelligent as non-believers and I was trying to explain why I thought that stigma existed. Many people who are raised Christian don't really think about what they believe and are happy to accept any answer given to them as long as it is an answer. The Bible also urges believers not to listen to people who would challenge or question its wisdom so intelligent discourse is often discouraged within religions as well, which could be another reason why Christians aren't seen to be as logical or intelligent as non-believers. Obviously you're not among this group and that's commendable. Again, my apologies.

Just also to touch on your last point, this thread has been about Hell and why it's fair and just to burn me for eternity, so you can see why I don't always feel the love from Christians. I get that some parts of the Bible send a nice message and many Christians try to follow that, but you'll rarely find any atheists who are like this either:
http://www.vulomedia.com/images/47196mrgruff.gif

Just like you sincerely believe Heaven exists and want everyone to enjoy it too, atheists sincerely believe that there is no God and no afterlife and that many Christians are wasting the precious time they have on Earth by obeying arbitrary rules and customs. I suppose that there is as much a preconception that Christians are unintelligent as there is that atheists are bitter, angry trolls who attack Christian beliefs for sport. Lets all agree to drop both of them now.

Sam said...

If I may please caution the inclusion of concepts such as science in religious debates. There is a general lack of understanding of science from both sides of the arguement, that often causes much grief to some.

That said I think you're are slowly approaching what I mentioned earlier. There is no logic in religion, therefore neither side can argue logically either for nor against.

It is a belief, it is non-falisfiable, and as such there is no proof for or against. It is a personal consideration of ones place in this world. Neither right nor wrong.

Christians often consider Atheists to be heathens, and Atheists consider Christians to be religious extremists.

You might think that both parties are trying to help the other in pushing their agenda, however perhaps you (in this thread) are all intelligent enough to see that attempting to 'help' your peers will only lead to contempt from both sides.


On a side note, don't use Einsteins name in vain, his scientific appreciation of religion was merely an appreciation for that outside of our extremely limited human perception of our far more complex world. He was using the term religion entirely differently to the conotations which you are assigning it.

Jared said...

"There is no logic in religion".
I think this is where the problem lies. I believe that religion can be argued logically. The content of the Bible frequently contradicts itself and any important claims it makes are unable to be proved or disproved. Unfortunately the burden of proof is on the believers to justify their claims and this is yet to be met. The logical conclusion at this point is that there is no reason to believe the Bible.

Anyway, I'm glad we've moved on from discussing who said a mean word first. Maybe we can get back to debating something with substance.

Sam said...

"Unfortunately the burden of proof is on the believers to justify their claims and this is yet to be met."

This is incorrect.

There is no need to attempt to prove belief. This is where you are wrong.
I'm not saying that the relgious people are right, i'm just indicating that there is no onus on them to prove anything to you.

Just as you cannot prove them wrong.

Jared said...

I agree that if we all just say 'to each their own' and stop worrying about it we'd have no need to prove our beliefs to each other, but many Christians seem intent on saving my soul, or at the very least are content to tell me I'll end up in Hell if i keep going the way I am.

But regardless of whether this can be definitively proved either way, I'd still be happy to continue this discussion if anyone else is. There's a lot of things about Christianity I don't understand (like the free will paradox I outlined earlier, for instance) and I'd be interested to hear a Christian's take on these issues. Sorry if my determination to question everything sometimes manifests as antagonism. While I confess to being an atheist I'm still interested in understanding both sides of the argument.

Sam said...

It's good to see that you're interested in both sides of the arguement, however if you continue to pursue the attempted to find valid logic behind the views and beliefs of your Christian counterparts, I fear only frustration shall ensue.

I agree that it is frustrating when Christians try to place a pon you their values, but in my eyes it is no different to student politicians harrasing you for your vote over student elections.

Both are annoying, however I doubt you feel the need to argue with the politicians over their attemps to persuade you (note, you may argue their ideals, i'm talking purely their attempt to get your vote), however when someone religious does it you find it perhaps more personal.

I'm not looking to stop debate, purely to make sure you're aware that in trying to endlessly find sense where there is none (at times) you're being futile.

Think about it as searching for light in a room of complete darkness, there is no light source, but if you close your eyes you may be able to convince yourself otherwise.
Unless you're willing to close your eyes, your search will be forever futile, you're better off opening the door and leaving the room, and getting on with your life =P

Jared said...

Haha um I think I've got a little lost in your analogy. You're saying the only way to make sense of what the Bible says is to stop trying to make sense of it...?

Jared said...

Oh well, thread over. Good night sweet prince.