Saturday, October 23, 2010

dear honi...

Dear Honi,

My letter is in response to Jared and Ruby. I hesitate in writing here, because tone can be really difficult to communicate, and that is no triviality when the topic is something as personal and sensitive as gay marriage. I hate the antagonism and hurt which has marred this social conversation.
But I have a few things to say.

The first is this: The callous lovelessness with which Christians have treated those who are homosexual is sinful. It appalls God.

Christians seek to represent Jesus to the world. And we screw it up, royally. Every day.

To illustrate: Jesus said to consider others better than myself. I am proud and self-preoccupied. Pride is the rebellion (‘sin’) that God detests most. Jesus said to care for the poor and sick. I rarely do this, and only when it is convenient for me. Jesus said to love those who mock me. Instead, my pride pricks up and I get defensive. Jesus hung out with the people who the religious gurus (Pharisees) had rejected as “sinners”. The Church is often Pharisaical, alienating the kinds of people that Jesus probably would be hanging out with.

I am sorry for all this, because I have, we have, often butchered Jesus’ words by the way we live.

Secondly, although there is diversity amongst Christians, and there is not one monolithic Christian voice, I think Jared’s right, and Christians shouldn’t be exempt from public criticism. (Just quietly, somehow I don’t think we ever would be. I’m fairly confident that until the day Jesus returns, we’ll still be the butt of every joke.)
Please DO hold us to account for our lovelessness in the way we’ve engaged in this discussion. Heck, God certainly does.

But I do not think that the Christian view of marriage is inhumane. I see marriage as something instituted by God, in which a man and a woman are united by God, under God and for God. To speak plainly, that understanding of marriage isn’t exactly inclusive of my married friends who don’t believe there IS a God. Does that mean they can’t get married?? No! As Ruby noted, there is a difference between the legal institution of marriage and the Christian institution of marriage.

Thirdly, Jesus wasn’t on about politics and legislating to legally enshrine His way of life. He had a bigger agenda; you know, saving humanity and stuff. I genuinely believe that as the One by whom and for whom we were made, that the way Jesus calls us to live is the best, and intended, way for us to live. I don’t force it on my friends, but I do think that living with Jesus as Lord of my life is better – forgot “morality”, I’m talking “better” in terms of joy, satisfaction, deep peace and contentment. But I don’t understand the logic that I should expect someone who doesn’t know Jesus to live like Jesus is their Lord. You come to Jesus as you are; then he commences heart renovation. Not the other way ‘round.

I agree that Christians shouldn’t have a disproportionately influential voice in public debate. But I don’t think that warrants the conclusion that we aren’t allowed a voice.

Because tolerance doesn’t mean always agreeing. Tolerance means loving someone, even when you disagree.

Steph Judd

No comments: